Today’s Paper#masthead-section-label, #masthead-bar-one { display: none }Trump Administration
A federal judge ruled that the Agriculture Department lacked the authority to approve state waivers that restrict what SNAP participants can buy with their benefits.
Listen · 2:36 min Share full article191The decision on Monday, by a federal judge in Washington, was a rollback of restrictions that officials have characterized as a major achievement of the Make America Healthy Again movement.Credit...Nic Antaya for The New York TimesBy Linda Qiu
!function(){if(document.body.classList.contains("gps-show")){var e="1"===new URLSearchParams(window.location.search).get("gps_debug")?function(e,t){console.log("[gps]",e,void 0!==t?t:"")}:function(){},t=document.getElementById("gpsModule"),s=document.getElementById("gpsLink");document.body.classList.contains("gps-lang-es")&&t.setAttribute("aria-label","Añade a The New York Times a tus fuentes preferidas en Google.");var n=t.closest('section[data-testid="inline-interactive"]'),c=n&&n.id||"google-preferred-source",r=t.closest('[data-testid="region"]'),i=r?r.id.replace(/^NYT_/,"").replace(/_REGION$/,""):"body";e("analytics init",{moduleContext:c,moduleRegion:i}),s.addEventListener("click",function(t){try{localStorage.setItem("gps_suppress_module","1"),e("click: suppression set")}catch(e){}var n=t.target.textContent.trim(),r={event_data:{pagetype:"article",type:"click"},module:{context:c,name:"google-preferred-source",region:i,element:{name:"google-cta",label:n,url:s.href}}};e("click: sending analytic",r);try{window.UnifiedTracking.sendAnalytic("moduleInteraction",r),e("click: analytic sent")}catch(e){console.error(e,"gps: failed to send click",r)}}),function(){var t=0;try{t=parseInt(localStorage.getItem("gps_module_impressions"),10)||0,e("read impressions",t)}catch(e){}function s(e){try{return JSON.parse(e.response).data.user.userInfo.entitlements||null}catch(e){return null}}function n(s){if(e("subscriber check: entitlements",s),function(e){return!!Array.isArray(e)&&(e.includes("TPR")||e.includes("HD")||e.includes("MTD")||e.includes("MSD")||e.includes("MM"))}(s))if(t>=10)try{localStorage.setItem("gps_suppress_module","1"),e("subscriber check: subscriber at cap — suppression set")}catch(e){}else e("subscriber check: not yet at cap, currently:",t);else e("subscriber check: not a subscriber, no suppression")}var c=window.userXhrObject;if(c){if(4===c.readyState)return e("subscriber check: XHR already complete"),void n(s(c));e("subscriber check: waiting for XHR"),c.addEventListener("load",function(){n(s(c))})}else e("subscriber check: no userXhrObject found")}()}}() (() => { const mount = document.currentScript.previousElementSibling; const tmpl = mount?.previousElementSibling; if (tmpl?.tagName !== 'TEMPLATE' || !mount.classList.contains('mount-point')) return; const frag = tmpl.content.cloneNode(true); const scripts = [...frag.querySelectorAll('script')]; scripts.forEach(s => s.remove()); mount.appendChild(frag); const run = i => { if (i >= scripts.length) return; const old = scripts[i]; const s = document.createElement('script'); for (const a of old.attributes) s.setAttribute(a.name, a.value); if (old.src) { s.onload = s.onerror = () => run(i + 1); mount.appendChild(s); } else { s.text = old.textContent; mount.appendChild(s); run(i + 1); } }; run(0); window.registerInteractive?.("100000010805361"); })(); A federal judge on Monday blocked the Trump administration from barring the use of food stamps to buy sugary drinks and candy.
Since last year, the Agriculture Department has approved waivers in more than 20 states that allow them to bar participants in the federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program from using their benefits to buy soda, energy drinks, candy or other prepared desserts. In March, recipients in five states sued the agency over the waivers, arguing that the limits were unlawful and confusing and made it difficult to manage health conditions like diabetes.
Judge Amy Berman Jackson of the Federal District Court in Washington, in a 68-page decision, agreed with the recipients that the Agriculture Department did not have the authority to approve the waivers and also failed to abide by a notice period. Monday’s decision was a rollback of restrictions that officials have characterized as a major achievement of the Make America Healthy Again movement.
Judge Jackson wrote that while the law allows for the department to approve projects related to the administrative and logistical efficiency of the SNAP program, the agency essentially “purports to waive not just a mere administrative or technical obstacle, but the very definition of ‘food’ as it was laid down by Congress.”
“The federal defendants and the states may have a genuine desire to improve the health of SNAP households by encouraging healthy choices at the store, and they can take lawful steps to meet those goals,” she wrote. “But what they cannot do is violate the law and their own regulations along the way.”
The case was brought by the National Center for Law and Economic Justice, a nonprofit that advocates on behalf of low-income people, and Shinder Cantor Lerner, an antitrust law firm.
Katharine Deabler-Meadows, a senior attorney at the National Center for Law and Economic Justice, said in a statement that the decision was “a major step in restoring essential food assistance to the millions of families that rely on SNAP nationwide.”
The Agriculture Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment about the ruling. A spokesperson for the agency had earlier told The Associated Press that it “will not be backing down from the fight to Make America Healthy Again.”
Linda Qiu is a Times reporter who specializes in fact-checking statements made by politicians and public figures. She has been reporting and fact-checking public figures for nearly a decade.
